prev next
  • decorated sugar cookies
  • decorated sugar cookies
  • decorated sugar cookies
  • decorated sugar cookies
  • Beer themed decorated sugar cookies
  • wedding decorated sugar cookies
  • decorated sugar cookies
  • decorated sugar cookies
  • decorated sugar cookies

Decorated Sugar Cookies

*Due to price inflation of supplies, ingredients and the amount of time/work that gets put into custom cookies, please be aware of my new pricing starting in 2022. Minimum 1 dozen per order. All cookies will come individually heat sealed in cellophane bags for freshness. The prices below are for custom orders.  Holiday pre-sale cookie & graduation pricing may differ.

Tier I Custom Cookies - *12 cookie minimum

Start at: $6/cookie - Simple decorating, up to 2 colors, basic airbrushing, minimal stenciling

Tier II Custom Cookies - *12 cookie minimum

Start at: $7/cookie - Pricing will include unlimited colors & design options, airbrushing, stenciling

Tier III Custom Cookies - *12 cookie minimum

Start at: $8/cookie - Pricing will include unlimited colors, design options, advanced airbrushing, hand painting including metallic, florals, etc. 

Cookies will be approximately 2.5 - 4.5”

Our signature flavor is Vanilla.  

*Flavors available - Cinnamon, Chocolate or Lemon $6 extra per dozen *12 cookie minimum
*Premium Flavors available - Chai or Funfetti $9 extra per dozen include *12 cookie minimum


Simple Filler Sugar Cookies *1 color only $36/dozen with/without sprinkles.

Add - On Options

Individually bagged, tied with a bow: additional $5 per dozen


*  All cookies will be individually heat sealed for freshness at no extra charge

Paint Your Own - $6/each

Individual 4” + cookies with a design of your choice (based on what I have available). Each PYO cookie includes a paint palette of 3-5 colors & a paint brush. Each cookie is heat sealed in a cellophane bag. Great for Valentine’s, Christmas and children’s birthday parties.

*Paint Your Own Cookie Options:
Valentine's Day, St. Patrick's Day, Easter, Teacher Appreciation, Halloween, Thanksgiving, Christmas, Monster Truck, Dinosaur, Unicorn, & Donuts options which are great for children's birthday's or great activities at a wedding children's table.  

Gluten Friendly Paint Your Own Cookies - $7 each

Cookie Sets

Starting: $20/set*

*$100 minimum (sets of 2-6 cookies)

Unlimited colors

Florals, detailed piping and

designs, metallics, painting etc.

come packaged in box with ribbon.

*No minimums on holiday pre-sales


prev next
  • decorated sugar cookies
  • decorated sugar cookies
  • decorated sugar cookies

Email me at confectionsbykaren@gmail.com to inquire about your cookie or treat order. The more information you include in your email the better I am able to assist you.  You may also contact me at 507-340-0171

Ordering Policy

If you are interested in my services please email me for a no-obligation quote or feel free to call me to discuss your options. **For all custom orders such as decorated sugar cookies payment is required in full before work begins.